|
Rating a book can be a real challenge. Sometimes it’s easy, especially
with the very good or the very bad ones. Sometimes it’s obvious,
especially with the many average stories that a reviewer reads. But what
does a reviewer do when she enjoys a book very much but has a sneaking
suspicion that her response will not be shared by the vast
majority of romance readers? This is the dilemma I face in evaluating
Wilma Counts’ new release, The Viscount’s Bride.
There seems to be an unwritten rule in current romance writing that the
hero and heroine must meet on page one, quickly develop a relationship,
and then spend the rest of the book trying to overcome the various
barriers to the happily ever after. Certainly the pair must spend most
of the book in each other’s company or at least be thinking primarily of
the other most of the time. There is certainly a rule that the romance
must be the at the center of the story. Finally, especially with
romances set during the Regency era, there is a general understanding
that the unpleasant realities of the era should not intrude excessively
into the tale. The Viscount’s Bride breaks all of these rules and
understandings, written or unwritten.
At least the hero and heroine are familiar characters. Theo
Ruskin, Viscount Amesbury, is the heir to an earldom and a veteran of
the Napoleonic Wars. He has finally returned to England in 1817 after
serving in the army of occupation in France. Newly elevated to the
position of heir due to the death of his elder brother in a carriage
“accident,” Theo is haunted by his wartime experiences and somewhat at
loose ends as he tries to find his feet in the civilian world. Hence,
when his father - at the instigation of several powerful politicians -
suggests that Theo use his talents for disguise to try to discover the
true state of public opinion among the lower orders by masquerading as a
common laborer in the northern mills, Theo agrees.
Hannah Whitmore is a vicar’s daughter, dedicated to the education of the
poor. Her father holds the living in the Derbyshire town of Crofton, the
seat of the Earl of Glosson, Theo’s father, and the site of the Glosson
woolen mill that adds considerable wealth to the family coffers. She has
established the Crofton Parish Day School which is successfully
educating a large number of the local children. However, she dearly
wants the children of the mill workers - many of whom are already
employed - to enjoy the benefits of an education.
Hannah and Theo actually meet first at a London ball. She has
accompanied her school friend to the affair; he is there at the
insistence of his mother who believes it is time for Theo to find a
wife. The two dance together; there is an immediate spark between them.
It looks like the romance is underway. But then the two do not really
meet again until page 96. In the interim, Hannah has returned to
Crofton, continued her educational activities, and joined the Crofton
Corresponding Society, a local group associated with the then widespread
political agitation for reform. Theo has found employment in the local
cotton mill owned by the unpleasant Lord Mayfield, discovered just how
demanding and demoralizing factory work is, and been unmasked. He is now
trying to uncover the dishonesty of his steward and to find out who was
responsible for his brother’s “accident.”
OK, you say; now our hero and heroine are in the same neighborhood and
the romance can begin, however belatedly. Sorry. This isn’t what
happens. Oh, yes, the two begin to interact occasionally, generally with
Hannah lumping Theo with the other antediluvian local factory owners,
until he demonstrates that he is a different kind of employer. And yes,
the attraction that was there from the start does develop. But they
don’t do much about it. Indeed, it takes their being unwittingly found
in a compromising position on page 273 to bring them together.
So by all the standards and expectations of the romance genre, The
Viscount’s Bride doesn’t work. Then why am I awarding the book the
coveted four-heart rating? Simply because this is a very good work of
romantic historical fiction, a genre which has fallen into
disfavor since the rise of historical romance some twenty or thirty
years ago.
Romantic historical fiction does have a hero and heroine; it does have a
romance; it does have a happy ending, at least for the couple. But it
has something more - an accurate recreation of historical events which
impinge in a meaningful way on the hero and heroine. I think especially
of the early works of Roberta Gellis which, though often categorized as
romances, are really romantic historical fiction.
The Viscount’s Bride fits very well into this almost lost
tradition. The historical events upon which it is based are the
widespread popular agitation for reform that arose out of the hard times
that followed the end of the wars and the inhumane conditions of workers
in the expanding industrial world of early 19th century England. The
response of the fearful ruling class - those suave aristocrats who are
the typical heroes of romance novels - was not attractive. The use of
spies and agents provocateurs, the harsh punishments - hanging at worst,
transportation at best - for those who sought change, the willingness to
use force against peaceful protesters are all chronicled in The
Viscount’s Bride. This is the darker side of Regency England and
Counts brings it vividly to life.
Thus, my four-heart rating. I enthusiastically recommend this book to
those readers who are willing to accept The Viscount’s Wife for
what it is, a fine work of historical fiction.
--Jean Mason
|